The Best TV Shows Set In Pennsylvania

Fact Checked by Thomas Leary

There’s no shortage of television shows that have been set in the state of Pennsylvania over the years, ranging from cult classics like NBC’s “The Office” to comedy dramas on the network like “This Is Us” and the ABC mockumentary “Abbott Elementary.”  

All of those small screen success stories that are centered around Pennsylvania got us wondering as to which TV show set in the Keystone State locals love the most, which is why we broke down the numbers to see who took home the top spot overall.  

World Television Day is November 21. To celebrate, PennStakes.com took a break from covering Pennsylvania sports betting to find the best shows set in the state. We used IMDB ratings, Rotten Tomatoes Audience score, Rotten Tomatoes Critic score, and awards recognition to create a weighted scoring system.  

Ranking Best Shows Set In Pennsylvania

Rank 

Show 

Total Points 

This Is Us 

381 

Abbott Elementary 

323 

The Office 

298 

Pretty Little Liars 

112 

The Goldbergs 

47 

Boy Meets World 

44 

American Rust 

27 

Lucky Hank 

24 

I Am Not Okay With This 

17 

10 

Mindhunter 

12 

Which PA TV Show Won Out?

With a total score of 381 points, NBC’s “This Is Us”, which is set in Philadelphia, beat out ABC’s “Abbott Elementary,” with the former scoring 381 points while the latter had 323 points to finish ahead of “The Office,” which was third overall with 298 points.  

While “Abbott Elementary” is also centered around the City of Brotherly Love, “The Office” takes place in the blue collar town of Scranton, while No. 4 “Pretty Little Liars” is set in the fictional town of Rosewood, with the teen drama scoring 112 points to finish ahead of No. 5 “The Goldbergs,” which had 47 points.  

Throw in “Boy Meets World” (44 points), “American Rust” (27 points), “Lucky Hank” (24 points), “I Am Not Okay With This” (17 points) and “Mindhunter” (12 points) and you have the full list of the top TV shows set in the Keystone State, though none could hold the cultural carte blanche that “This Is Us” holds in Pennsylvania, based on the digital tea leaves known as search interest points.  

USA Today photo by Dan MacMedan.

Author

Christopher Boan

Christopher Boan has been covering sports and sports betting for more than seven years, including stops at ArizonaSports.com, the Tucson Weekly and the Green Valley News.

Cited by leading media organizations, such as: